When Meaningless Becomes Meaningful

Photo by kyle smith on Unsplash

“Can’t hear you!” (that’s Dan)

“Yeah, I know…coming” (that’s Karen)

We have this exchange at least four times a day. We’ve lived in a tiny house for six years, so small that we assume that if we talk loudly enough, our words will carry across the short space between the bedroom and the living room.

You would think two reasonable, intelligent people could remember that our hearing isn’t what it used to be. But there are other, less obvious reasons for our repeated exchange.

I talk to myself, out loud, incessantly.

“Can’t hear you!”

“Ignore me—talking to myself again.”

“OK.”

How is Dan supposed to know when I am talking to myself or talking to him when it all sounds like a slightly muffled, incomprehensible human voice emerging from someone he loves?

We haven’t figured this out. Maybe we never will.

But there is more…

“Did you remember to call…”

“Where did you put the…”

Not only do I talk to myself, but I often don’t finish sentences. This is usually because I assume Dan can finish any sentence I begin. We have been married for several decades, and I am a non-stop sharer of my thoughts, fears, and plans.

But Dan, a precise person and a chess player who knows that every move is critical and deserves attention, views this incompleteness as a potential harbinger of impending mental decline. He always finishes his sentences and never uses incorrect or muddled grammar.

“Can you finish that sentence?”

“You know what I’m saying!”

“Yes, but I want you to finish the sentence.”

How many times a day do we have this exchange?

Talking to myself? Talking to him? Him receiving my messages, whether spoken or unspoken? Our mutual acknowledgment that this is not an argument or even a point of real disagreement, but a habit, a way of saying, without words, “I am still here. Here for you. We care for each other. We know this exchange will happen again in a few hours.”

Affection and desire for connection, communicated with words that have little apparent emotional content.

This is not new. I had something similar with my parents. I can hear my father saying, “Time to get off the phone” as clearly as I can see him almost smiling, reminding me that when he grew up, no one chatted on the phone because there were shared party lines, with other people listening in. I responded, “Just one more minute, Daddy!” And then I stayed on for four or five.

All I wanted was a princess phone in my own room. It wasn’t going to happen. My father loved me, but he viewed the phone as a convenient way to communicate information, not as a means of affirming a bond. Connecting with him meant paying attention while we were in the same room. He wanted me to be there, but he had no idea how to talk to a teenage girl, so, well, we didn’t. He lit his pipe and looked at me thoughtfully, which passed for talking

I understood, and still relish the smell of pipe tobacco; his last pipe, with tooth marks that make me smile, sits as a small shrine in my house.

Now Dan and I continue to blur the boundaries between “I need you to know” and “I want some attention from you.”

“Can’t hear you!”

It’s all part of connecting, with love, when we still can’t read each other’s minds.

Photo by Yunus Tug on Unsplash

Leave a Reply